Showing posts with label books I read in half hour chunks at lunch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books I read in half hour chunks at lunch. Show all posts

Thursday, October 3, 2013

"The Three Orders"

The Three Orders: Feudal Society Imagined (Georges Duby, translation by Arthur Goldhammer)

I have to give Barnes and Noble some credit here; As much as I complain about their history section being nothing but Hitler and annoying gimmicks (ex. Salt), they've launched a line of books called "Barnes & Noble Rediscovers" that re-prints old, interesting books like this. I then have to remove almost all said credit because they felt the need to stick not one, but TWO of those horrible price stickers on the dust jacket, the kind that refuse to come off and leave a big smear of old glue and sad paper that you can't remove even with water and a paper towel.
So what was I talking about? Right, this book. I'm glad this book was "rediscovered", because it's probably the most readable book out there about the schema of medieval French society being made up of the titular three orders, those who pray, those who fight, and those who work the land, and oh man does that ever sound tedious now that I'm typing it out. I know it sounds bad, but I found this book to be pretty interesting and surprisingly readable. My only caveat is that you really have to pay attention, because if you let your mind wander away from the text you can skip down half a page without realizing it and become totally lost. I suppose saying it's the best concentration-demanding 400 page tome on the organization of medieval society isn't much of a compliment, but if you've made it this far without being scared off, I'd recommend at least checking it out of your local library.

Grade: B?

Friday, July 5, 2013

"The Secrets of Alchemy"

The Secrets of Alchemy (Lawrence Principe)

I feel like I'm repeating myself lately when making statements that my biggest complaint about a book is that I wanted more of it, but I can't help it. This is a slim little tome (Amazon says 296 pages, but I think the main text barely topped 200) - in this small space the author fits in both a history of alchemy and several practical experiments he conducted following the ancient instructions. This is rather fascinating, not to mention pretty educational, and as alluded to above, my only gripe was that I wanted the author to go more in-depth on the history and do more experiments with the classical recipes. On the other hand, I don't want to give the impression that the author is only skimming the surface; the history section goes so far as to include a section on the cultural impact of alchemy and chemistry, including several poems that are more fun than they have any right to be when read aloud to your wife at Applebee's. So uh, recommended.

Grade: A

Sunday, September 11, 2011

"First Man"

First Man: The Life of Neil A. Armstrong (James Hansen)

The imaginitively named authorized biography of Neil Armstrong (not to be confused with the Albert Camus book of the same name). I feel for the author; Armstrong is apparently legendarilly taciturn, which makes for a lot of sentances like "Neil doesn't remember..." or "Neil couldn't confirm that..." This may sound annoying, but I found it kind of charming; Armstrong's quiet, reserved self-confidence seems very commendable to me (and familiar; Armstrong reminds me of a certain someone's older sister, actually). What does get annoying is how technical the book can be. I understand - in fact, I applaud - the level of care and detail that goes into the moon landing (and the preparation and immediate aftermath). What I don't understand is why this level of detail is gone into for the entire part of the book leading up to the moon landing. Do we really need to be given a rundown on the difference between the average height and weight of the first versus the second group of astronauts (to provide one example)? The amazon review points out that the author actually counts up how many shells, bombs, and rockets were fired per month when Neil is a fighter pilot in the Korean war, and this is exactly as boring and as tedious as you think it is - any interesting events are rendered lifeless by an endless parade of dry technical details and meaningless figures. The author even starts early, giving us 10 generations of the Armstrong clan before Neil is even born. Bizarrely, the opposite occurs at the end of the book -after the moon landing, it's like a switch has been flipped; The remainder of the book - and there isn't much - is basically "Uh, then he never gave any interviews, the end."

My recommendation: The moon landing and the parts immediately surrounding it are about a third of the book, and they're a great third of a book. This is where the author's endless attention to detail is a powerful positive instead of a deadly dull negative, and what could in the wrong hands be boring (since you know the outcome already presumably) or tedious (given the amount of technical detail) is where the book shines and almost makes plodding through the rest of it bearable. The thing is, you don't really need to plod through the rest of the book. Skip until when Neil starts working as a test pilot, and close the book after he returns home from the "Giant Step" tour coming off the moon landing. You'll have a well-written, gripping account. Read the whole thing, like I did, and you'll have a slog with a cracking middle. (Admittedly, the author remains humorless, managing to turn Buzz Aldrin's amusing anecdote about being the first man to pee his pants on the moon into a paragraph-long investigation of who truly peed in his pants on the moon first, but this somehow feels fitting given Armstrong's character and desire to get it right, no matter what makes the best story.)

Grade:
If you just read the part I recommend: A-
Entire book: C-

Sunday, July 10, 2011

"The Secret History of MI6"

The Secret History of MI6 (Keith Jeffery)

Here's an odd bird: An offical history of a secret intellegence organization. Bear in mind this is the real history of MI6 (nee SIS), so instead of James Bond parachuting away from an exploding blimp and snowboarding down the mountain he lands on while outrunning the fireball, you're going to be reading about people trying to get jobs in shipyards and stealing documents from the garbage.
Now that's all well and good and I wish I could recommend this book, but I can't. The book is weirdly dry and bloodless. A lot of the book - feels like 90% at times - is wasted detailing SIS' endless reorganizations, which is just as exciting as it sounds. My eyes started glazing over and then I started skipping pages as SIS got reorganized again and again, with the nadir coming as the section on SIS activites in World War 2 threatens to get exciting and is hit like a car on the train tracks by another fucking reorganization.
With that out of the way, the remaining material is pretty interesting - my favorite parts actually come almost at the end of the book when Q branch starts up and begins wrestling with stuff like a safe that can destroy everything in it in the time it takes a man to run up the stairs. But the "remaining material" is very sparse; Most of the book is a bureaucrat's view of SIS, where everyone is minuting thier asses off about how the organization should be set up. Not terribly thrilling, in other words, and tough to recommend unless you're adept at skipping large chunks, or really, really interested in the permanent under-secretary minuting about the report prepared by Sir Biffy Tushsniffington about which Section of SIS should report to which branch controlled by which assistant director. A sad missed opprotunity.

Grade: D+