Cartoons of World War 2 (Tony Husband)
I don't have much to say about this book; this is one of the ones you can judge from the cover. I liked it well enough, and I got my fill for the $8 I paid, but the book could stand to be a little bit bigger; it's more of a sampler than a thorough exploration of the material. Fun to flip through if someone leaves it out in the bathroom, but that's about as glowing as my recommendation gets.
Grade: B
Showing posts with label comic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comic. Show all posts
Thursday, September 25, 2014
"Cartoons of World War 2"
Labels:
art book,
bathroom book,
comic,
history,
I want MORE,
nham
Sunday, June 15, 2014
"A Centaur's Life" Volume 1
A Centaur's Life Vol 1 (Kei Murayama)
A goofy slice-of-life manga about (checks title) a centaur and her two high school buddies, a tomboy "draconid" (nothing exciting, she just has pointed ears) and a kind of personalityless "goatkind" (who has big cat ears on top of her head for some reason). The art is really nice, it's pretty funny, and I learned a lot ("A centaur's undergarments" are "big"!) , but I do have kind of a hard time recommending you run out and spend $13 on a book that takes 45 minutes to read. See if you can borrow it from a friend.
Grade: B
A goofy slice-of-life manga about (checks title) a centaur and her two high school buddies, a tomboy "draconid" (nothing exciting, she just has pointed ears) and a kind of personalityless "goatkind" (who has big cat ears on top of her head for some reason). The art is really nice, it's pretty funny, and I learned a lot ("A centaur's undergarments" are "big"!) , but I do have kind of a hard time recommending you run out and spend $13 on a book that takes 45 minutes to read. See if you can borrow it from a friend.
Grade: B
Monday, September 30, 2013
"Blankets"
Blankets (Craig Thompson)
I was a little tough on the first Thompson book I read, a graphic novel called Habibi that reached for greatness and couldn't quite grasp it. Weirdly enough, his previous work - this book - is everything I could have asked for and more. I don't want to gush too much, but this book is beautifully written and drawn, at turns hilarious and heartbreaking (mostly heartbreaking) as it follows our hero Craig and his struggles growing up.
I guess if I'm looking for some criticism, the art in Blankets isn't as breathtaking as it is in Habibi, both because this is earlier in Thompson's career and because the setting is more stark and less fantastical - and come to think of it, that's more of an observation; the stark art in Blankets perfectly fits the tone of frozen Midwestern lost despair. Huh. Well, I guess for once I can't think of a single thing to complain about. Um, highly recommended.
Grade: A+
I was a little tough on the first Thompson book I read, a graphic novel called Habibi that reached for greatness and couldn't quite grasp it. Weirdly enough, his previous work - this book - is everything I could have asked for and more. I don't want to gush too much, but this book is beautifully written and drawn, at turns hilarious and heartbreaking (mostly heartbreaking) as it follows our hero Craig and his struggles growing up.
I guess if I'm looking for some criticism, the art in Blankets isn't as breathtaking as it is in Habibi, both because this is earlier in Thompson's career and because the setting is more stark and less fantastical - and come to think of it, that's more of an observation; the stark art in Blankets perfectly fits the tone of frozen Midwestern lost despair. Huh. Well, I guess for once I can't think of a single thing to complain about. Um, highly recommended.
Grade: A+
Labels:
almost 1000 f'n pages,
autobiography,
comic,
depressing,
graphic novel,
loved the end,
MASSIVE,
nham,
read in one sitting
Saturday, September 21, 2013
"Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths"
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths (Shigeru Mizuki)
This is a "90% autobiographical" retelling of the author's WW2 experience. As you can probably guess from the title, it's quite grim - early on our group of heroes is detailed to go on a suicide charge, but commit the crime of coming back alive after news of their noble deaths has already been spread to the rest of the army as a morale-booster, and it only gets worse from there.
Despite the sheer hopelessness of the material presented within, the author's style is so gripping that it's almost impossible to put down. Mizuki combines very realistic backgrounds (and tanks, planes, and ships) with cartoon-styled people, and this technique gives each person a lot of personality; it's impossible not to feel for these guys getting slapped around, not getting enough to eat, and worrying about getting eaten by alligators. The grimness of the material is the only caveat I'd apply, and I would hasten to add that while you'll feel horrible after finishing the book, this is a story that deserves to be told.
(Discussion question: Is it tasteless to apply the "didn't like the end" tag to the ending of a book titled Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths?)
Grade: A
This is a "90% autobiographical" retelling of the author's WW2 experience. As you can probably guess from the title, it's quite grim - early on our group of heroes is detailed to go on a suicide charge, but commit the crime of coming back alive after news of their noble deaths has already been spread to the rest of the army as a morale-booster, and it only gets worse from there.
Despite the sheer hopelessness of the material presented within, the author's style is so gripping that it's almost impossible to put down. Mizuki combines very realistic backgrounds (and tanks, planes, and ships) with cartoon-styled people, and this technique gives each person a lot of personality; it's impossible not to feel for these guys getting slapped around, not getting enough to eat, and worrying about getting eaten by alligators. The grimness of the material is the only caveat I'd apply, and I would hasten to add that while you'll feel horrible after finishing the book, this is a story that deserves to be told.
(Discussion question: Is it tasteless to apply the "didn't like the end" tag to the ending of a book titled Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths?)
Grade: A
Labels:
autobiography,
comic,
depressing,
didn't like the end,
graphic novel,
history,
nham
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Rent Girl
If you ever want to see a sex worker or currently see sex workers, you are not going to want to read this book. While the author/main character never feels degraded by her job, she hates both her job and her clients. She is also kind of mean.
Wednesday, July 10, 2013
"Absolute Promethea" (Book 3)
Absolute Promethea: Book Three (Alan Moore, J.H. Williams III & Mick Gray)
Not to be confused with Prometha: Book Three, this is actually Books Four and Five collected in one huge volume. (I know it's confusing; this is what happens when you switch formats halfway through a series!) Since Promethea only runs to five books, this collection wraps the series up. Upfront, I'll say that it's quite good, and then I'm going to get into some minor spoilers...
A big part of this book is Promethea getting ready to end the world, with the series just about wrapping up as she does so. However, her actions don't really bring around anything like the end of the world. Instead, it's more like she's giving out a revelation. There isn't any widespread distruction, and the only people who die are people who kill themselves because of what she tells them. This is certainly tragic, but not exactly the END OF THE WORLD!!! that so many of the book's other charecters were trying so hard to prevent throughout the book. Also, the revelation she gives out falls a little flat to me; maybe you had to be there.
Anyways, the spoilers are over, and that one issue aside, this is quite good. Actually, wait, there is one other thing; the last issue is Promethea talking directly to the reader, and while I would have really liked to read this, the backround of every page is a huge garish rainbow smear of color, rendering it basically unreadable. Even in this extra-large format under a strong lamp, I could feel my eyes writhing in terror at trying to make out the text.
So that's really the only negative things I can say. Since this is the Absolute edition, there's some nice extras at the end, including two mini-comics about the least-seen aspect of Promethea drawn in early 20th century style that I found quite charming. All in all, if you've come this far you owe it to yourself to finish the series, and if not, uh, I really hope you didn't read those spoilers up there.
Grade: A-
Not to be confused with Prometha: Book Three, this is actually Books Four and Five collected in one huge volume. (I know it's confusing; this is what happens when you switch formats halfway through a series!) Since Promethea only runs to five books, this collection wraps the series up. Upfront, I'll say that it's quite good, and then I'm going to get into some minor spoilers...
A big part of this book is Promethea getting ready to end the world, with the series just about wrapping up as she does so. However, her actions don't really bring around anything like the end of the world. Instead, it's more like she's giving out a revelation. There isn't any widespread distruction, and the only people who die are people who kill themselves because of what she tells them. This is certainly tragic, but not exactly the END OF THE WORLD!!! that so many of the book's other charecters were trying so hard to prevent throughout the book. Also, the revelation she gives out falls a little flat to me; maybe you had to be there.
Anyways, the spoilers are over, and that one issue aside, this is quite good. Actually, wait, there is one other thing; the last issue is Promethea talking directly to the reader, and while I would have really liked to read this, the backround of every page is a huge garish rainbow smear of color, rendering it basically unreadable. Even in this extra-large format under a strong lamp, I could feel my eyes writhing in terror at trying to make out the text.
So that's really the only negative things I can say. Since this is the Absolute edition, there's some nice extras at the end, including two mini-comics about the least-seen aspect of Promethea drawn in early 20th century style that I found quite charming. All in all, if you've come this far you owe it to yourself to finish the series, and if not, uh, I really hope you didn't read those spoilers up there.
Grade: A-
Labels:
alan moore,
comic,
didn't like the end,
fantasy,
graphic novel,
MASSIVE,
nham
Sunday, July 7, 2013
"Promethea" (Book 3)
Promethea: Book 3 (Alan Moore, J.H. Williams III & Mick Gray)
It's been a while since books one and two (the perils of poaching books off your wife's shelf). Luckily I didn't feel too lost picking up here, although it took me a minute to remember what happened at the end of Book 2 - someone was killed, if that's the right word, and this book picks up with Promethea going after her. To do this she journies into the Sephirot (the Tree of Life, not the bad guy from Final Fantasy 7), which makes up basically all of this book.
And how is it? Pretty good. The writing's what you would expect from Alan Moore, and while apparently some reviewers didn't enjoy the mysticism, I'm not sure why you'd still be reading this series if that was a turn off. (I mean, this is a series where our heroine gets her powers by writing poems about imagination.) The art is also quite nice, although there are a few hiccups (one section done entirely in black and red that I think is supposted to be scary comes off more as eye-punching). I don't really have anything negative to say about this book; if you've already started reading the series, there's no reason not to get it, but I guess you don't really need me to tell you that.
Grade: A
It's been a while since books one and two (the perils of poaching books off your wife's shelf). Luckily I didn't feel too lost picking up here, although it took me a minute to remember what happened at the end of Book 2 - someone was killed, if that's the right word, and this book picks up with Promethea going after her. To do this she journies into the Sephirot (the Tree of Life, not the bad guy from Final Fantasy 7), which makes up basically all of this book.
And how is it? Pretty good. The writing's what you would expect from Alan Moore, and while apparently some reviewers didn't enjoy the mysticism, I'm not sure why you'd still be reading this series if that was a turn off. (I mean, this is a series where our heroine gets her powers by writing poems about imagination.) The art is also quite nice, although there are a few hiccups (one section done entirely in black and red that I think is supposted to be scary comes off more as eye-punching). I don't really have anything negative to say about this book; if you've already started reading the series, there's no reason not to get it, but I guess you don't really need me to tell you that.
Grade: A
Tuesday, April 30, 2013
"The Infinite Wait"
The Infinite Wait and Other Stories (Julia Wertz)
When this blog started waaaaaay back in April 2011, Wertz's previous book Drinking at the Movies was the sixth review published. I only wish I'd started this blog before reading her first two books (the wonderfully named "Fart Party" volumes 1 and 2). Drinking at the Movies is a fairly straight narrative, and I think The Infinite Wait suffers slightly in comparison to it, both because some of the material is re-hashed, and because it's separated into three non-connected sections of Wertz's life. I enjoyed this book, but given its re-telling of some of the same parts of her life, I almost wonder if Wertz either needs to have more stuff happen to her before her next book, or start doing non-biographical work. In any case, I don't want to give the impression that this book is bad; it's merely got a few issues holding it back from greatness. It's also the best comic book I've read in 2013 (disclaimer: only comic book I have read in 2013).
Grade: B+
When this blog started waaaaaay back in April 2011, Wertz's previous book Drinking at the Movies was the sixth review published. I only wish I'd started this blog before reading her first two books (the wonderfully named "Fart Party" volumes 1 and 2). Drinking at the Movies is a fairly straight narrative, and I think The Infinite Wait suffers slightly in comparison to it, both because some of the material is re-hashed, and because it's separated into three non-connected sections of Wertz's life. I enjoyed this book, but given its re-telling of some of the same parts of her life, I almost wonder if Wertz either needs to have more stuff happen to her before her next book, or start doing non-biographical work. In any case, I don't want to give the impression that this book is bad; it's merely got a few issues holding it back from greatness. It's also the best comic book I've read in 2013 (disclaimer: only comic book I have read in 2013).
Grade: B+
Labels:
comic,
graphic novel,
husband is wrong,
nham,
non-fiction,
not for kids,
very mean feeling hurter
Thursday, April 18, 2013
The Law of Superheroes
The Law of Superheroes
by James Daily and Ryan Davidson
Ever wondered if your favorite superhero might actually be breaking the law? Can the criminals Batman arrests actually be prosecuted? Just what citizenship rights does Superman have anyway? This is definitely the book for you. I found this book both a fascinating look into comics and law. We all tend to think certain things are obviously legal or permissible, but what does the law actually say? I highly recommend this book for people, like me, who spend their time wondering "Well, wait a minute...could they actually...?"
Grade: A
by James Daily and Ryan Davidson
Ever wondered if your favorite superhero might actually be breaking the law? Can the criminals Batman arrests actually be prosecuted? Just what citizenship rights does Superman have anyway? This is definitely the book for you. I found this book both a fascinating look into comics and law. We all tend to think certain things are obviously legal or permissible, but what does the law actually say? I highly recommend this book for people, like me, who spend their time wondering "Well, wait a minute...could they actually...?"
Grade: A
Monday, November 5, 2012
"A Bride's Story, Vol 1"
A Bride's Story, Vol 1 (Kaoru Mori)
A very well drawn, charming manga I couldn't really get into. The setting is interesting and unusual, but this seems to be a a slice-of-life book - in other words, nothing really happens; There's one chapter about making rabbit stew. I mean, it's not bad, and the art is nice to look at, but it's just not my personal taste. (Also, the titular Bride is kind of a mary sue.) There's worse ways to spend some time than reading this, but I wasn't gripped, which makes this hard to recommend.
Grade: B-
A very well drawn, charming manga I couldn't really get into. The setting is interesting and unusual, but this seems to be a a slice-of-life book - in other words, nothing really happens; There's one chapter about making rabbit stew. I mean, it's not bad, and the art is nice to look at, but it's just not my personal taste. (Also, the titular Bride is kind of a mary sue.) There's worse ways to spend some time than reading this, but I wasn't gripped, which makes this hard to recommend.
Grade: B-
Labels:
badly needs an editor,
bathroom book,
comic,
graphic novel,
husband is wrong,
nham
Friday, August 10, 2012
"Black Orchid"
Black Orchid (Neil Gaiman)
There's one great moment in Black Orchid, and it appears right off the bat. (It's also spoiled in the introduction, which I recommend you skip). Unfortunately, once this great moment is passed, the shock, interest, and forward momentum it generates is disappated as the story wanders around and becomes boring and, in the last chapter, nonsensical. In this last chapter, the heroine's ex-husband - a gun runner with no combat skills - somehow and without explanation becomes Billy Badass, sneaking around the jungle blow-darting mercenaries and sneaking up on and murdering a character who's presented as a great hunter. Even worse is the ending, which I am about to spoil:
At the end, the bad guys, paid mercs and thugs, catch up with our heroine, who they've flown down to Brazil to kill or capture, and have been following her through the jungle for days. When they finally catch up to her, they refuse to kill her, because "she's beautiful". Then they leave. Seriously. This is really what happens.
Apparently this is one of Gaiman's first books, and he obviously got better, but I honestly can't even recommend this for Gaiman completions. You're not missing anything except some nice art and one great moment, and that falls pretty short of the price of admission.
Grade: D
There's one great moment in Black Orchid, and it appears right off the bat. (It's also spoiled in the introduction, which I recommend you skip). Unfortunately, once this great moment is passed, the shock, interest, and forward momentum it generates is disappated as the story wanders around and becomes boring and, in the last chapter, nonsensical. In this last chapter, the heroine's ex-husband - a gun runner with no combat skills - somehow and without explanation becomes Billy Badass, sneaking around the jungle blow-darting mercenaries and sneaking up on and murdering a character who's presented as a great hunter. Even worse is the ending, which I am about to spoil:
At the end, the bad guys, paid mercs and thugs, catch up with our heroine, who they've flown down to Brazil to kill or capture, and have been following her through the jungle for days. When they finally catch up to her, they refuse to kill her, because "she's beautiful". Then they leave. Seriously. This is really what happens.
Apparently this is one of Gaiman's first books, and he obviously got better, but I honestly can't even recommend this for Gaiman completions. You're not missing anything except some nice art and one great moment, and that falls pretty short of the price of admission.
Grade: D
Sunday, August 5, 2012
"Swallowing The Earth"
Swallowing The Earth (Osamu Tezuka)
Apparently Tezuka is the "God of Manga", and here's a manga from him. And, uh, it's good. Like Promethea, I feel like I'm doing a disservice to explain too much of the plot, so the very broad outline is that the story kicks off with two soldiers looking for a mysterious woman named Zephirus who's up to no good, with our hero soon turning up in the shape of a drunk named Gohonmatsu Seki, who attempts to figure out what she's up to and maybe stop it in between getting drunk and unloading cargo down at the dock. There's a lot more to it than that; at heart the book is an adventure story, although individual chapters can be at turns comedic, heartbreaking or - as the book goes on and synthetic skin shows up - skin-crawlingly creepy. The art's very nice, dating from back before manga became very stylized, with a more cartoony flavor to it. The only caveat I'd apply here is that there's a lot of nudity and violence - the book suggests readers over 16 - and that, having come out in Japan in 1968, there's some, um, dated depictions of South Seas islanders and American black people in the book. If you can look past this (or just read disclaimer about this issue, which is among the first things you see when opening the book), you shouldn't pass this up.
Grade: A
Apparently Tezuka is the "God of Manga", and here's a manga from him. And, uh, it's good. Like Promethea, I feel like I'm doing a disservice to explain too much of the plot, so the very broad outline is that the story kicks off with two soldiers looking for a mysterious woman named Zephirus who's up to no good, with our hero soon turning up in the shape of a drunk named Gohonmatsu Seki, who attempts to figure out what she's up to and maybe stop it in between getting drunk and unloading cargo down at the dock. There's a lot more to it than that; at heart the book is an adventure story, although individual chapters can be at turns comedic, heartbreaking or - as the book goes on and synthetic skin shows up - skin-crawlingly creepy. The art's very nice, dating from back before manga became very stylized, with a more cartoony flavor to it. The only caveat I'd apply here is that there's a lot of nudity and violence - the book suggests readers over 16 - and that, having come out in Japan in 1968, there's some, um, dated depictions of South Seas islanders and American black people in the book. If you can look past this (or just read disclaimer about this issue, which is among the first things you see when opening the book), you shouldn't pass this up.
Grade: A
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Hark! A Vagrant
I'm a big fan of Kate Beaton so I was super excited to get this one. Contains funny comics about such topics as Georges Danton, the Bronte sisters, and a very fat Shetland pony. A lot of the comics are on her site for free, it's true. BUT. Supporting someone like Beaton with cold hard cash is worthwhile. Must read for history nerds and webcomic fans.
Grade: A++
Grade: A++
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)